Sunday, September 16, 2018

Concert Review: A Long Trip to Jupiter

The New York Philharmonic brings back 2001.
by Paul J. Pelkonen
Class in session: the man-apes and the Monolith in 2001: A Space Odyssey.
Image © 1968 Warner Bros. Used for promotional purposes only.
What is 2001: A Space Odyssey really about?.

Stanley Kubrick's seminal 1968 classic is now 50 years old, and remains as puzzling as ever. On Friday night, as part of this year's The Art of the Score festival, the New York Philharmonic performed the complete orchestral and choral music of 2001 as accompaniment to a large scale screening of the film at Lincoln Center.



This was the first of two performances, and the first "repeat" of this festival, as 2001 had been featured as the opening movie when the festival launched back 2013. Here, the orchestra was led by conductor André de Ridder and joined by the men and women of Musica Sacra, regimented into two small choruses positioned in box seating in the first tier of David Geffen Hall.

2001 was birthed a collaboration between Stanley Kubrick and the late science fiction author Arthur C. Clarke. (The novel was written in parallel to the screenplay and expands on some of the more cryptic moments in the film.) It is an unusual film in every respect: meditative, slow-paced and presenting its images and skeleton plot with a minimum of dialogue. And its score, which featured music by Richard and Johann Strauss (no relation) and the choral music of Gyorgi Ligeti, is actually made from Mr. Kubrick's temporary music cues used during production. An actual score was written (by composer Alex North) but was never used.

The plot of 2001 concerns a series of interactions between humans (at various stages of development from primitive hominids to space-faring scientists) and an alien presence represented by a mysterious black slab of unknown material and origin. This one-by-four-by-nine shape (commonly referred to as "the monolith") is many things: a cryptic teacher that shows the Australopithecines (pictured above) how to use tools, a signalling device, and at the film's climax a cosmic gateway that transits astronaut David Bowman to a locale best described as "beyond the infinite."

The music assembled to accompany the film's visuals: the Dawn from Richard Strauss'
Also sprach Zarathustra (commonly known outside the provenance of the music business as "the 2001 theme"), The Blue Danube waltz by Johann Strauss Jr. (no relation) and the slow movement from Khachturian's ballet suite Gayaneh appear in between the scenes with dialogue: serving as majestic, playful and serene accompaniments to the momentous movement of spacecrafts and satellites. The music of Ligeti (Aventures, Atmosphères, part of the Requiem and Lux Aeterna) accompanies every time the alien influence (in the person of the Monolith) shows itself.
It could thus be argued that the excerpts used here from these four Ligeti pieces   provide not just exotic accompaniment for the strange journeys and psychedelic ending of this film: but they give the listener a sort of primer in terms of how to experience and listen to the music of the 20th century. In that, the act of screening 2001 is a valuable thing in and of itself: teaching the audience and showing the power and beauty of works that, were they programmed on a regularly scheduled concert, might draw less of an enthusiastic reception.

On Friday night, everything (with the notable exception of the malfunctioning, paranoid and ultimately murderous computer HAL-9000) worked perfectly. Mr. de Ridder drew a majestic performance of both Strausses' music. (The "Dawn" is excerpted from a much longer piece, and The Blue Danube is heard twice in its entirety.) However it was the Ligeti that was the most powerful and memorable, an eerie series of wordless melismas accompanying the mind-bending visuals onscreen. The Art of the Score is a valuable Philharmonic tradition and this performance helped cement it. One hopes that next year's presentation will be as creative and inspirational.